Is It Ethical to Use No Bark Collars?
19 Oct 2009
Today, there are three different methods that are used in no bark dog collars. All of them work, but there is some debate as to whether these collars are ethical to use. As a dog owner, you should know about the no bark dog collar you want to use on your noisy pet.
Spray Collars
Some no bark collars work by emitting a spray of citrus smell if the dog barks for a while. Dogs don't like this smell, so they will stop barking in order to avoid it. Some collars also give a warning “hiss” sound, so the dog can stop barking before the smell is sprayed on its muzzle if he listens and heeds the warning sound. Professional dog trainers and veterinarians consider the use of these collars ethical, since the dog feels no pain and can even avoid the discomfort.
Sonic and Ultrasonic Dog Collars
These collars work by emitting a very high pitched sound when the dog barks. This tone is similar to the dog whistle sound. Most humans can’t hear it or be annoyed by it, but dogs can and will stop barking once they realize that when they stop barking the high pitched tone goes away. Again, experts and trainers don't feel that these collars are unethical, as there is no pain or injury to the dog. Dogs only get a bit annoyed, and they learn how to avoid that eventually. Note: This is the least effective type of no bark collar, as dogs can get used to the sound over time, so don't overdo it.
Electronic No Bark Collars
When the electronic collar “hears” the dog bark, it gives the dog a mild electrical shock. The shock isn't painful, it's similar to what you feel when you handle fabrics or walk over a rug. However, there are a lot of people that think that this type of no bark collar is unethical. The main reason why these people consider this collar unethical is that it actually causes a physical stimulus that can be felt by the dog. Some people don’t like that. However, these collars are very effective for reducing excessive barking, so take them at least into consideration.
To deter a dog from barking excessively, you can choose from no bark collars that use citronella spray, sonic or ultrasonic sounds, or electronic shocking. Most people have no problems with spray collars or sonic collars, but the idea of an electrical shock makes them think that shock collars aren't good for dogs. None of these methods are considered dangerous for dogs.
Leave a reply